A Guide to Underpayment Recovery for Healthcare Providers

Not every paid claim is rightfully reimbursed. Sometimes, underpayments in healthcare occur when an insurance carrier reimburses at a lower rate than your contracted rate. If you want to prevent underpayments, you must: (1) establish an accurate baseline rate, (2) centralize contractual governance, (3) perform internal audits to review actual and expected reimbursements, (4) utilize automated payment variance reports, (5) filter out claims where actual payment was lower than the contracted rate, (6) regularly audit zero-balance accounts, and (7) analyze patterns to identify root causes.

Immediately marking processed medical claims as paid ones in your practice management (PM) software and closing the account is the biggest mistake you can make. The reason? Getting a reimbursement does not always mean you are paid correctly.

That is, you sometimes receive underpayments rather than your actual contracted rates due to incorrect fee schedules, processing errors, or unnecessary bundling of procedural codes.

Understanding healthcare underpayments, their causes, and the recovery process is essential because they are difficult to identify. This guide covers everything that you need to understand to secure your lost revenue before it is too late. So, continue reading!

What Are Healthcare Underpayments?

It is a legally recoverable variance in your reimbursement. It primarily occurs when an insurance payer reimburses you an amount lower than what is specified in your fee schedule, negotiated contract, or payment policy.

However, it is different from claim denials. That is, denials result in zero reimbursement, whereas underpaid claims are completely processed by the payer. Simply put, the claim has a paid status, but it is not fully paid.

Besides, healthcare underpayments are hard to spot. The reasons are discussed below:

  • Electronic Remittance Advice (ERAs) post payments directly into your PM software as per the standard claim status code. That is, it does not reconcile whether the reimbursed amount matches the contracted rate.
  • The system automatically closes the account and sets the balance to $0 when you post payer write-offs and patient liability.
  • Contracted rates are not the same for every insurance plan.

How Much Revenue Do Underpayments Cost Practices?

Did you know that hospitals absorbed $130 billion in healthcare underpayments from federal programs (Medicare, Medicaid) in 2023 alone?

Here’s an example to help you better understand how underpayments in healthcare work.

Imagine a mid-sized practice that processes approximately 15,000 claims of average value $150 and expects $3,000,000 in annual collections. 

If the insurance carrier underpays claims by just 1% across fee schedules per claim due to rate errors or incorrect bundling, the revenue loss will be as follows:

Loss Per Claim = $150 x 0.01 = $1.50Annual Lost Revenue = $3,000,000 x 0.01 = $30,000

Causes of Underpayments in Healthcare Billing

Discussed below are the key reasons causing underpayments in healthcare:

1. Payer-Related Issues

Many times, the cause behind underpayments is payer-related. These common issues include:

1.1 Outdated Fee Schedules

There may be scenarios where the insurance payer fails to update or load its pricing systems with updated fee schedules or newly negotiated contractual rate increases.

Example: Picture a physician whose contract stipulates a 4% annual rate increase starting from January 1 for CPT code 99214. 

However, the payer’s administrative team fails to update this new schedule and reimburses the claim at the previous year’s contracted rate. This results in a 4% healthcare underpayment for every established patient, outpatient E/M visit with moderate decision-making.

1.2 Improper Downcoding or Bundling

Today, most insurance payers are using automated adjudication software. This can also lead to healthcare underpayment as the algorithm is set to reduce the level of service code or auto-combine distinct procedural codes into a single lower-paying code if documentation lacks medical justification.

1.3 Misapplied Payer Policies & Edits

What happens when insurance carriers inappropriately apply National Correct Coding Initiative (NCCI) edits, misinterpret complex contract terms, or ignore billable modifiers? It also results in healthcare underpayments. 

1.4 Adjudication System Errors

If the payer’s system inaccurately processes coordination-of-benefits (COB), makes calculation errors, or applies patient deductibles and copays incorrectly at the payer level, it can also lead to healthcare underpayments.

Example: There may be scenarios where a patient has both primary and secondary insurance plans. In such situations, the primary payer can make an error while calculating COB. That is, let’s say the primary payer reimbursed only 60% when they should have paid 80% of the procedure cost.

2. Provider-Side Billing Issues

Billing-related errors that originate during initial patient registration and charge capture before claim submission also lead to underpayments in healthcare. These include:

2.1 Coding & Modifier Errors

When selecting codes, you need to ensure that your diagnosis code properly aligns with the procedural code. Make errors here or append the wrong modifier, and it can also lead to healthcare underpayments.

2.2 Documentation Gaps

Inadequate documentation is also a major culprit that leads to healthcare underpayments. How? Simply put, documentation is the blueprint that billers use to code the claim. Thus, when it is incomplete, it leads to charge capture breakdown, such as omission of billable ancillary services, supplies, and secondary procedures from the final claim. 

3. Gaps in Revenue Cycle Management

Structural weaknesses in revenue cycle management (RCM) can also trigger healthcare underpayments. These include:

3.1 Overreliance on Zero Balance Closure

Do your RCM experts automatically adjust any remaining balances to contractual write-offs during payment posting? It is a common practice, so a ‘yes’ is not an issue. However, writing off balances without validating the payment to the fee schedule results in underpayments in healthcare.

3.2 Lack of Contract Management Integration

Does your billing software have integrated contract management rules? If not, it cannot automatically adjust payment variances, calculate reimbursement, or flag payment variances against actual remittance.

3.3 Ineffective Appeal Workflow

Practices without dedicated workflows to track, appeal, and escalate recurring payment variances often lose their rightful revenue to healthcare underpayments.

How to Identify Healthcare Underpayments?

Listed below are some of the proven ways to identify underpayments in healthcare:

1. Accurately Set an Expected Reimbursement Baseline

Start by setting an expected reimbursement baseline within your billing software against every contractually active procedural code. 

Also, remember to factor in complex contract terms beyond basic fee schedules. These include:

  • Annual fee schedule updates and escalation clauses.
  • High-cost drugs or surgical supplies.
  • Location-based or specialty-specific rate differentials.
  • Multiple Procedure Payment Reductions (MPPR).

2. Centralize Contractual Governance

Next, you should obtain and centralize the following insurance carrier documentation to enforce your expected reimbursement rules:

  • Avoid relying on outdated internal estimates. Instead, request the insurance carrier to provide you with complete CPT/HCPCS allowable matrices.
  • Integrate all applied policies related to modifier payment percentages, bilateral rules, and NCCI edits into your billing software.
  • Retrieve signed Medicare Advantage, MCOs, and private payer agreements to confirm base rate terms and effective dates.

3. Audit Actual & Expected Reimbursement

Received reimbursement? Do not consider it a job done. Instead, reconcile remittance data against your established reimbursement baseline. Here’s how:

  • Review Remittance Advice Remark Codes (RARCs) and Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARCs) to determine the reason for payment differences.
  • Always compare the allowable amount in your contract with the remittance adjustment amounts posted in your PM software. 
  • Ensure that all line items on your submitted claim are paid accurately.

4. Utilize Automated Payment Variance Reports & Contract Modeling

When you solely rely on manual comparisons of every Explanation of Benefits (EOB), you should be prepared for human oversight. However, leveraging automation can be a game changer. Here’s how:

  • Implement an automated contract rules engine to calculate expected reimbursement upon charge entry and flag line-item variances when the ERA posts.
  • Run weekly or monthly variance reports to filter paid claims where actual payment is less than the contracted rate.
  • Ensure that the reports highlight single-line and total-claim healthcare underpayments.

5. Regularly Audit Zero-Balance Accounts 

Note that underpayments are often swept under the rug in closed accounts. The reason? Automatically adjusting the remaining balance as a contractual write-off clears the claim from A/R follow-up pipelines that target aging claims, open balances, and active denials.

Thus, you should perform regular audits of a sample or utilize an automated tool to scan 100% of zero-balance accounts closed over the past 30-90 days. This will help you identify unnecessary write-offs.

6. Analyze Patterns to Identify Root Causes 

Frequent healthcare underpayments often point to internal billing workflow issues, gaps in RCM, and payer algorithm issues. Therefore, you should analyze payment variances across multiple dimensions to identify systemic root causes. These include:

  • Identify payers that consistently underpay or ignore negotiated rate increases and hide it behind incorrect/outdated fee schedules in the internal system.
  • Track high-value (e.g., surgeries) or high-volume (e.g., E/M visits) codes where insurance carriers systematically bundle or downcode services.
  • Determine the exact date a payer shifted its adjudication logic or when a newly negotiated contract rate failed to load.

Step-by-Step Healthcare Underpayment Recovery Process

Let’s review how you can ensure successful healthcare underpayment recovery:

Step # 1: Identify & Filter Payment Variances

Do the following:

  • Run automated variance reports to filter ERA/EOB remittance data where actual payment is less than the contracted rate weekly.
  • Prioritize high-value accounts first by setting an actionable triage limit, e.g., claims short by $25 or more. Also, batch smaller, high-volume micro-variances for bulk processing.
  • Isolate zero-balance accounts where healthcare underpayments were unnecessarily written off as contractual adjustments.

Step # 2: Identify the Root Cause

Here’s how you can investigate the real reason behind underpayments:

  • Review CARC and RARC codes on the EOB to understand why the insurance carrier underpaid the claim. 
  • Review documentation to verify the claim was billed with appropriate diagnosis/procedural codes, modifiers, and complete clinical documentation.
  • Cross-reference the date of service on the claim against active payer contracted rates to confirm the expected reimbursement baseline.

Step # 3: Categorize the Error

Another step in the insurance underpayment recovery process is to categorize reasons for underpayments to execute the correct recovery workflow:

Root Cause CategoryPrimary TriggerAction Plan
Patient Financial ResponsibilityUnapplied copay, coinsurance, or deductible.Reallocate balance to patient billing statement.
Coding and Billing ErrorMissing modifier, wrong diagnosis/procedural code selection, and incomplete documentation.Submit a corrected claim.
Payer Adjudication ErrorUnloaded fee schedule, stripped modifier, or improper downcoding.Issue a formal contract dispute or payer appeal.

Step # 4: Execute the Dispute or Correction Pathway

Based on the identified cause, you should execute either the dispute or the correction workflow for underpayment recovery. That is, take path A if the cause was coding/billing related at your end, path B if it was payer-related, or path C if it was the patient’s financial responsibility:

Path A (Billing/Coding Error)

  • Rework the claim, add corrected CPT/HCPCS codes, or/and append missing modifiers.
  • Submit the updated claim as a Frequency Code 7 with the original claim reference number to prevent duplicate claim denials. For context, frequency codes are used on claim forms to identify the claim nature. For example, 1 (original claim), 7 (replacement/reworked claim), and 8 (void claim).

Path B (Payer-Related Issue)

  • Draft a targeted contractual appeal citing the specific contract section, active fee schedule rate, and date of service.
  • Attach the supporting documentation. These include:
    • The original EOB
    • Clinical notes if the payer has underpaid due to a lack of medical necessity or questioned the modifier application.
    • Relevant page of the signed contract.
  • Dispute the underpayment by submitting all these documents using the payer’s preferred method.

Path C (Patient’s Financial Responsibility)

  • Transfer the unpaid amount from the payer line item to patient responsibility in your PM software.
  • Issue an itemized patient statement. It must include the primary insurance adjudication and an explanation of the remaining out-of-pocket balance.

Step # 5: Track, Escalate, and Collect

Submitting a corrected claim or disputing payer-related issues is not enough. You must implement a proactive workflow to ensure successful underpayment recovery. Thus, do the following: 

  • Log appeal submission dates, tracking numbers, and payer representative details in your PM software.
  • Proactively monitor your appeal status against payer-specific appeal filing limits.
  • If you are receiving lower payments from one specific payer against a specific procedural code, escalate bulk variances directly with your provider relations account manager.

Step # 6: Prevent Repeated Healthcare Underpayments

Implement the following best practices to stop recurring underpayments at the source:

  • Immediately update newly negotiated contract rates and annual fee updates in your RCM contract management system.
  • Optimize your scrubbing tool with custom rules to flag missing modifiers or incomplete charge captures before claims are submitted.
  • Train the payment posting team to never write off underpayments as contractual adjustments without cross-checking actual reimbursement against the contracted fee schedule.

How NeuraBill Helps Providers Recover Underpayments?

Let’s say you have identified healthcare underpayments following the information available in this guide. Now what? If you handle your medical billing and revenue cycle management operations in-house, you can initiate the recovery workflow we discussed in this guide. 

However, if you want professional help recovering the lost revenue without hiring billing and RCM experts in-house, it is better to outsource revenue cycle management to professionals at NeuraBill. 

What makes it a smart decision? First of all, NeuraBill is a full-service RCM company that handles follow-up, documentation, and appeals related to underpayment recovery. Moreover, it provides other supported services, including billing audits, medical billing, denial management, old A/R recovery, and insurance credentialing.

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest

Related Post

Table of Contents

Get in Touch with a Medical Billing & RCM Expert

Request a Call Back

Get a Quote